Was Homer Wrong?

[Mathew]

Sorry, but that reads as though you left a few words or some punctuation out. If I've misconstrued your two one liners and they were not meant to be personal attacks or demeaning, then that's fine. Others will form their own views of your "Perhaps you think the strings are pulling the hands - if you do your intellect is rivaled only by that of garden tools" proposition.

It has obviously gotten to you - at least my attack (if it was an attack) was towards an arguement and therefore indirect... Yours wasn't...

This time it is because you chose to answer a question which wasn't asked.

Well actually you quoted Homer Kelley and i'm explaining a part of it....just you don't realise it...

How many times do I have to answer the same question....

You are right that you can write responses in any form you choose.

Which would be clearer to you if you spend enough time to read and understand the language of the book.

I reject your claimed sovereignty over what my duties are and where any onus lies unless of course it is part of the terms and conditions of this web site.

It is up to those who wish to disprove any theory to do so...

Homer Kelley is unfortunately not with us anymore which means that he is no longer around to be in a position to talk on such matters.

[golf_sceptic]

It has obviously gotten to you

Nope. I've read some of your other posts. You've got some really good ideas, and your ideas seem well received here. Good luck with them.

I'd be delighted if you choose to follow yoda's lead in this thread and continue to discuss the topic. I'm only interested in the physics underlying TGM though. I'm happy to let others judge your words to me. That's about all I have to say to you really.

[Mathew]

I'm happy to let others judge your words to me. That's about all I have to say to you really.

Thats fine ....

especially the "centrifugally powered golf swing" snideness

Still waiting to see where Homer has said it is centrifugally powered....

[golf_sceptic]

Still waiting to see where Homer has said it is centrifugally powered....

The discussion has moved on Mathew.

If you want to contribute, you might start by looking at yoda's posts and my responses. Numerous other people are also making strong contributions, and yoda and everybody else appear to have immediately understood what I'm here to discuss. I'm enjoying my time here immensely.

[Mathew]

The discussion has moved on Mathew.

If you want to contribute, have a look at yoda's posts and my responses.

Firstly it is not your place to tell me what conditions I can contribute to. Secondly we are still on this subject.....centrifugal force.... just tell me where he said "centrifugal powered".

Other people are also making strong contributions and looking forward.

Looking forward .... as in you in comparison to Homer - are you a comedian....

[golf_sceptic]

Firstly it is not your place to tell me what conditions I can contribute to

Quite right! You'll notice that I edited my post to include the words "might like". I did this whilst you were replying and completed the edit after your reply. It's your choice Mathew. You must decide what your contribution is to be. I'm here to discuss physics.

[Mathew]

You'll notice that I edited my post to include the words "might like". I did this whilst you were replying and completed the edit after your reply. It's your choice Mathew. You must decide what your contribution is to be. I'm here to discuss physics.

No kidding - I thought it was to discuss the weather

Perhaps you can again reference the quote from the golfing machine that says "centrifugal powered" that I pointed out with "snideness".