[nevermind]

Unfortunately I don't have my copy anymore, and without some other visual depicting what your saying is possible, a fourth stickmen for example, I just can't swallow it rwh, sorry However, I have found an answer that Mike O gave when I asked a similar question early last year

I think it's obvious that the right shoulder is ideally just on-plane during the start-down. If it's thrusting - then ideally during that thrust period it would be on plane- but not necessary as you could have an offsetting thrust to balance it out if it was thrusting offplane- see 2-N-1 for that discussion. Of course, there are certain limited conditions/strokes where the right shoulder could be on-plane throughout the downstroke - but we're talking about the norm i.e. you'll have a tough time finding a professional who has their right shoulder on plane at impact- if not impossible. For those that think the right shoulder should/could be on plane throughout the downstroke then you'll need to clearly prove your point.

So in his opinion the stickman in the middle is closest to the real world reality.(hope that's right) I've seen photo's showing golfers using the TSP and looking like each of the stickmen, and I'm just curious which variant TGM would advocate. So far the middle guy is 1up. If you can draw a fourth alternative or post a pic of someone doing differently, please do. How bout the TSP's number one fan. Yoda?