[Yoda]

Food for the thought, Yoda...

Have always struggled trying to hit draws from where I believed a swinger should have the ball (more forward from my understanding), but was always more comfortable hitting draws with the ball back in the stance.

Uninterrupted, Centrifugal Force will align the Clubface for Horizontal Hinging through Impact. This means that the Clubface will be Square to the Target Line at only one point in its orbit through the Impact Interval. Before this point, the Clubface will be Open, and after this point it will be Closed. Thus, for the 'True' Swinger, positioning the Ball forward brings a Closed Clubface into Impact and produces Draws and Hooks. Similarly, positioning the Ball back in the Stance brings an Open Clubface into Impact and produces Fades and Slices.

Hence, for the 'True' Swinger -- one who does nothing to override this action via intentional (or unintentional) Hand Manipulation -- the Ball must be precisely positioned for Straightaway Flight. This position varies with the design of each Club and can only be determined by experiment. Fortunately, the Clubs are manufactured to position themselves well for this Straightaway Flight, e.g., a Three-Iron positions itself further forward in the Stance than a Pitching Wedge. However, once the Ball Position has been determined for the Club in Hand, the 'Pure' Swinger must not interfere. Centrifugal Force has 100 percent responsibility for aligning the Clubface for Impact. And that means that if the Ball has been put too far back, a Slice must result, and if too far forward, a Hook.

Hitters and 'Manipulated Hands' Swingers, on the other hand, are not bound by the problem of 'One Straightaway Position.' Again, remember that we are not talking about one Ball Location for all Clubs, e.g., 'inside the Left Heel.' Instead, we are talking about a Straightaway Position unique to each Club. Players using Hand Manipulation can choose to play the Ball from this Straightaway Position, or they can position it further backward or forward. In other words, by Aiming Point (6-E-2) and Clubface Adjustment, they can hit the Ball Straight with any Club from any Location in their Stance.

The Aiming Point Adjustment can be determined only by experiment. The Clubface Adjustment is accomplished by positioning the Left Wrist Flat, Level and Vertical and turning the Club (more Open or Closed) in the Hand. This procedure -- 'Rotating the Grip' (7-2) -- aligns the Clubface appropriately to produce the intended Ball Response, i.e., a Straightaway or Curved Ball Flight.

So, Densikat, your difficulty in producing Draws from the Forward Ball Location was because you were not using the 'True' Swing technique. Instead, you were overriding the natural action of Centrifugal Force that brings a Closed Clubface into Impact with a Ball positioned forward of the Straightaway Point. Your success in producing Draws from the Back Ball Location is because you are correctly using Hand Manipulation to produce an Impact on the Outside-Aft Quadrant of the Ball.

One final thought:

It is extremely difficult for the 'True' Swinger to determine the necessary precise Ball Location for each unique Club and under all conditions and circumstances. Therefore, Homer Kelley felt strongly that 'Hand Manipulated' Swinging was by far the better alternative.