[whip]

Brian manzella has taken the stance that he wants to upstage homer and in fact point out how he didn't have some wallywho biomechanics 'expert' and a 16,000 dollar trackman to help himlike 21st century manzella. Gimme a f'n break...

I have heard many claims about the books errors and yet have really only heard two arguments and instances that he claims are wrong

1. Tgm is wrong because trackman shows that the ball leaves the face perpendicular at the point of maximum deformation and not separation like homer claims...

this is suppost to be a ground breaking argument? Again gimme a f'n break...
Once the ball is compressed to it's maximum it begins to decompress and is essentially chasing away from the clubface, in other words maximum deformation and separation are essentially The same time, DUH the ball once compressed to it's maximum cannot be acted on anymore by the clubface the time that it takes a maximum compressed golf ball to separate the clubface is such a tiny frame of time, fractions of a millisecond, to say that the difference between maximum deformation and separation are at al different is ridiculous and has absolutely no real argument. End of story

2. Tgm is wrong because homer said low point is at the left shoulder, when truly the lowest point of the clubheads arc can be anywhere.

Seriously? Again to a person who has no knowledge of Tgm can only read manzellas jive that Tgm is old and he is new not actually realizing that he has no real arguments to contrast the supposed old science. Of course the low point can be anywhere! DUH but if we are to have any kind of systematized way of controlling the golf ball and altering ball position for a given effect the geometry should be set for most full shots that the lowest part of the swing should be under the left shoulder, the hinge. Also the center point of the stroke doesn't have to be the head it can be anything, Brian , because he knows I will refute his claims on his own forum and for fear of his followers learning the truth , he has permanently banned me from his forum.

Nice try Brian get back to me when you have any sort of real arguments.