5th edition 10-19-0

[annikan skywalker]

Why did Homer delete this from the 6th edition?

Skywalker

[comdpa]

Most likely because he found that the circle delivery path was not as optimum as the straight line delivery path.

[annikan skywalker]

I greatly appreciate the response...

On what basis ....

do you feel that the circle path delivery is inferior to a straight line for swinging....

[MizunoJoe]

Maybe he thought that downcocking coupled with #4 leakage made a true straight line delivery path possible rather than just a straight line effort, which is the reality. I've never seen a straight line delivery path of more than an inch or so before it starts curving.

[tongzilla]

On what basis ....

do you feel that the circle path delivery is inferior to a straight line for swinging....

One does not have Secondary Axis Tilt (the one at Start Down) when using a Circle Delivery Path. Which means Right Shoulder cannot get On Plane to provide maximum support for the Stroke.

[annikan skywalker]

MJ,

Did you checkout Ben Doyle's delivery Path on the clip from www.brianmanzella.com/ forum?

[MizunoJoe]

skywalker - yes, if you step through it and use a straight edge, you can see that the path starts curving from the Top. When the angle is held that well it creates the illusion of a straight line. BUT, it is a straight line effort, and it's a larger radius arc than the circular path would be.

[Martee]

What page is that from in the book? I don't recall seeing that in 5th edition in that format.

[annikan skywalker]

p.192

[Martee]

p.192

Thanks...Duh I need to count better, I was in the wrong version and couldn't find it for the life of me.... Duh!!

Thanks again.